Google Ads


Site Stats

2010 House Open Seat Watch: A Look Back at 2007-2008

by: DavidNYC

Wed Oct 07, 2009 at 7:49 AM EDT


With the 2010 election season starting to heat up a bit in the House, we thought we'd take a look back at all the incumbents who didn't seek re-election to the 111th Congress, along with the date they officially announced they weren't running again (and their reasons).

District Incumbent Party Decision Date
CO-02 Mark Udall (D) Ran for senate 1-Jan-07
MA-05 Marty Meehan (D) Resigned 13-Mar-07
CA-52 Duncan Hunter (R) Ran for president 20-Mar-07
ME-01 Tom Allen (D) Ran for senate 8-May-07
IL-18 Ray LaHood (R) Retired 26-Jul-07
MS-03 Chip Pickering (R) Retired 16-Aug-07
OH-15 Deborah Pryce (R) Retired 16-Aug-07
AZ-01 Rick Renzi (R) Retired 23-Aug-07
AL-02 Terry Everett (R) Retired 26-Aug-07
MN-03 Jim Ramstad (R) Retired 17-Sep-07
IL-11 Jerry Weller (R) Retired 21-Sep-07
NM-01 Heather Wilson (R) Ran for senate 4-Oct-07
OH-16 Ralph Regula (R) Retired 11-Oct-07
OH-07 Dave Hobson (R) Retired 14-Oct-07
NM-02 Steve Pearce (R) Ran for senate 16-Oct-07
LA-01 Bobby Jindal (R) Elected governor 20-Oct-07
CO-06 Tom Tancredo (R) Ran for president 28-Oct-07
NY-21 Michael McNulty (D) Retired 29-Oct-07
NJ-03 Jim Saxton (R) Retired 9-Nov-07
NM-03 Tom Udall (D) Ran for senate 9-Nov-07
WY-AL Barbara Cubin (R) Retired 10-Nov-07
NJ-07 Mike Ferguson (R) Retired 19-Nov-07
IL-14 Denny Hastert (R) Resigned 26-Nov-07
LA-04 Jim McCrery (R) Retired 7-Dec-07
MS-01 Roger Wicker (R) Appointed to senate 31-Dec-07
PA-05 John Peterson (R) Retired 3-Jan-08
CA-04 John Doolittle (R) Retired 10-Jan-08
LA-06 Richard Baker (R) Resigned 15-Jan-08
NY-25 Jim Walsh (R) Retired 24-Jan-08
FL-15 Dave Weldon (R) Retired 25-Jan-08
KY-02 Ron Lewis (R) Retired 29-Jan-08
MO-09 Kenny Hulshof (R) Ran for governor 29-Jan-08
VA-11 Tom Davis (R) Retired 30-Jan-08
OR-05 Darlene Hooley (D) Retired 7-Feb-08
AL-05 Bud Cramer (D) Retired 13-Mar-08
NY-26 Tom Reynolds (R) Retired 21-Mar-08
MD-04 Al Wynn (D) Resigned 27-Mar-08
NY-13 Vito Fossella (R) Retired 19-May-08

Note: Mark Udall planned to run for Senate long before the 2008 cycle began, so we've just slotted him in at the top. And if you'd like to take a look back at Republican retirements in the 2006 cycle, click here.

As you can see, things unfolded rather differently over the last two Congresses, especially compared to what we've seen so far this year. Last cycle, there were already a number of outright retirements at this point (including several shockers, like Deborah Pryce and Chip Pickering), while only three reps had announced campaigns for higher office. There were also many more retirements to come, especially on the GOP side; the most fertile months for announcements turned out to be October-November and January.

This time, we have zero retirements and a whopping eighteen members of Congress who are running for a different job. It's easy to see why we have no retirements yet - Dems are in power, and the GOP is feeling better about its chances these days. I'm personally hoping that the combination of a real healthcare bill passing, plus some Dem victories in the three key races on Nov. 3 (NJ-Gov, VA-Gov & NY-23), will help re-demoralize the Republican Party and encourage some geezers to head for the exits. At the very least, barring some kind of crazy collapse on our side, we are extremely unlikely to see a repeat of 1994, when thirty Dems announced their retirements, and the GOP picked up twenty-two open seats. So far, there are just seven blue open seats this cycle, and only three are potentially competitive.

DavidNYC :: 2010 House Open Seat Watch: A Look Back at 2007-2008
Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
The importance of NY-23
There are currently many Rs who believe they can "take back" the House in 2010.

If Owens wins - 27 days from now, many more Rs will see that as a false hope, taking more of their leaders, tying them more to the Rush/Beck axis.


which is why
Im starting to lean for Owens.  The election being in November and it having some clear national implications makes it a race a bit too important to lose.

Agreed on that we haven't seen too many retirements as the GOP believe they are going to have a great year so why bail now and the Dems know they are in power and probably still will be so why bail now?

That was probably what drove so many retirements in fall-winter 07, we are going to lose even more seats so Im done.


[ Parent ]
I don't think it will have as big of a motivating/deflating reaction as people think
At least when it comes to the senate picture.  I mean, Republicans already got who they wanted to run in Illinois, Deleware, Pennsylvania (since Gerlach deferred), Kentucky (since Bunning retired), Florida, and New Hampshire.  

The only impact it'll probably have is the defeat to house members might get a handfull of members to retire, but with as many seats as we have, it's hard to tell where we'd get a good opportunity.  Most R-incumbents in swing territory have announced intentions to run for re-election, IIRC.  


[ Parent ]
Nothing to do with the Senate
All about the House. That is what the talk is. Nobody thinks they can win eleven senate seats. But if Owens wins in may stop some Dems retiring because it will show swing districts aren't going to fall like dominoes to the GOP. So I disagree. Imagine Owens, Corzine and Maine win on November 3 and the Repubs are left with Virginia. The media will talk it up in Dems favor.

[ Parent ]
Now I understand why there is so much pressure on the site in NY23
I agree that good Dem showings in VA and NJ along with a robust public option Health Care Reform will pick up spirits. I maintain that NY 23 is not the race for this purpose. A progressive R opposed by Club for Growth Conservative and a Democratic candidate to her right! Dede will give us a great across the aisle partner that we can use for bi-partisan cover on many pro-labor and social issues. This will be much more meaningful along with the need to build a progressive wing to the Republicans so that they can see the light of their extremist ways than winning one more seat for a centrist Democrat.

Until Boehner threatens her with a primary challenge
and we'd be lucky if she becomes another Susan Collins, watering down whatever we want for her vote.


[ Parent ]
DeDe's just another R on health care - pandering to teabaggers
per http://www.pressrepublican.com...

At an event sponsored by the NY Tea Party - she said

Scozzafava said several times that while rising health-care costs need to be contained, she does not see the need to totally revamp the system.

"I don't see what the rush is," she said.

If elected, DeDe will not provide any bipartisan cover, at least on health care.


[ Parent ]
Being right on two issues that will never come up in congress makes someone progressive?
Please.  

[ Parent ]
Um
ENDA, DADT, DOMA, FMA, or EFCA?

[ Parent ]
Bipartisan cover is useless
they'll water down the bill endlessly.  What we really need are more and better Democrats.  Owen may not be a progressive but he is one more Democrat, and for a district that basically hasn't elected one since the 19th century, I'll take that.

[ Parent ]
We have the more already. We need better.
If Owens won't support the public option, then fuck him.  We don't need another no vote for the biggest piece of Obama's legislative agenda to date (and possibly of his presidency).

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
I'd feel more comfortable
about Pelosi's ability to strongarm Owens into voting for the bill than about her getting Scozzafava to break ranks with the GOP (which will otherwise be unanimous).

[ Parent ]
Scozzafava panders to Teabaggers. Owens avoids them.
At least that's the lesson from the Teabagger forum I cited earlier.

So do you feel more comfortable with:

1) A "liberal" Republican who panders to teabaggers.
2) A "moderate" possibly even blue dog Northern Democrat who avoids teabaggers and has an open mind?

And when answering that question, keep in mind the impacts on R morale.


[ Parent ]
She is not a progressive
Not at all.

[ Parent ]
I have just renounced my endorsement of Scozzafava
The DCCC commercial where she asks, Whats the rush to reform health care put me out of play on her behalf. I never before endorsed a Republican for federal office but I honestly thought she was different. That question or just the ability to ask it seriously demonstrates that we are not better off with her in congress! Another Susan Collins? Youbetchya!

[ Parent ]
Thank you! Can you help with Kos?
As you're probably aware, Markos endorsed Scozzafava last week in the following diary - http://www.dailykos.com/storyo...

AFAIK, he has not changed his mind (yet).


[ Parent ]
Iam afraid Markos is more stubborn than I am!
I hope he reassess things between now and November! The WFP just endorsed Owens thus adding to what others have posted seriously questioning Scozzafava progressive pedigree!

[ Parent ]
Win in VA-Gov??
Even Deeds is acknowledging that he will have a hard time. He's already starting the blame game, blaming DC. Obama will also not return to VA

Is that certain?
Obama will also not return to VA


"I'm not a member of any organized political party, I'm a Democrat!"
--  Will Rogers  


[ Parent ]
Looks fairly clear, barring a big comeback
http://online.wsj.com/article/...

Deeds seems pretty done.  His lamentations about the national atmosphere earlier today smacked of defeat.

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11


[ Parent ]
However
Here are my Nov. 3 predictions
CA-10- Garmendi wins in a surpisingly close contest (in this district, that mean David Harmer comes within 7 % to me)

NY-23- Scozzafava quickly defines herself as a conservative, killing Hoffman's base, and after a very close recount, Scozzafava wins less than 500 votes

VA-Gov- McDonnell wins by about 3%

NJ-Gov- Corzine wins by less than a thousand votes, and Chris Daggett replaces Obama as the most hated man in the Republican party

Of these, I feel my predictions are most likely to change in NY-23 and NJ Gov


[ Parent ]
Who's in the recount in NY-23?
Hoffman or Owens?

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]
Owens is the close one


[ Parent ]
You've inspired me to predict as well.
CA-10 - Garamendi 59, Harmer 40
NY-23 - Owens 38, Scozzafava 37, Owens 25
VA - McDonnell 55, Deeds 45
NJ - Corzine 45, Christie 43, Daggett 9
ME - No 53, Yes 47

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]
I tend to have that effect on people ;)
And I'm assuming the 38% Owens is the real Owens, and the 25% is the Hoffman?
Surprised by the democrats pessimism in VA. I don't know about Maine, is No no to gay marriage, or no to keeping a current ban?  

[ Parent ]
Yes, 25% Hoffman
In Maine, no means yes to gay marriage.  Currently Maine allows it, so a "yes" is for a ban.

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]
Here's my take
CA-10:

Garamendi: 57%
Harmer:    43%

NY-23:

Scozzafava: 40%
Owens:     39%
Hoffman:   21%

NJ-Gov:

Corzine: 46%
Christie: 44%
Daggett: 10%

VA-Gov:

McDonnell: 54%
Deeds:  46%


[ Parent ]
As of now...
CA-10:
Garamendi - 54%
Harmer - 46%

NY-23:
Scozzafava - 42%
Owens - 39%
Hoffman - 19%

NJ-Gov:
Corzine - 44%
Christie - 44%
Daggett - 12%

VA-Gov:
McDonnell - 53%
Deeds - 47%

For daily political commentary, visit me at http://polibeast.blogspot.com/ and http://twitter.com/polibeast


[ Parent ]
Are people basing these predictions of a tight CA-10
On anything but that Harmer internal or have I missed something?

[ Parent ]
Yeah
Thats it. Garmendi also screwed up a tax question, saying he doesn't want to use the "t-word" but to solve budget issues you need to find ways of increasing tax revenue, and Harmer has been hitting him very hard on that, IDK if that is hurting him though

[ Parent ]
I'm sure Survey USA will have something soon
I'm not going by a fundraising pitch.

[ Parent ]
Another Christie blunder?
Facing an $8 billion shortfall Christie came up with $300 million in cuts.  Last night he said he'd fill the shortfall by pushing costs back to the municipalities.  Property taxes are already the worst in the nation.

He got away with it.  Maybe.  If anybody puts two and two together this is a super huge gaffe.  The towns are already both laying people off and putting many employees on unpaid furloughs.  And he's talking about "saving" the tax rebate at the same time.

This means that either Christie is terminally dumb or more likely he thinks NJ voters are incredibly stupid.  I'm going with the later.  And next month I will not vote for Christie I'll vote for Corzine.


[ Parent ]
That's a loser's argument
and what it means is that he's a bad campaigner and doesn't want to take personal blame for that.

"I'm not a member of any organized political party, I'm a Democrat!"
--  Will Rogers  


[ Parent ]
Rasmussen Vitter 46, Melancon 36
Vitter at 68-30 approval.  Anybody buying that?  And if that's true, wouldn't he likely have more than a 10-point lead and be well over 50% against Melancon, who purportedly has 33-30 approval?

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

Is that job approval?
Ras says his favorbles are 56 percent.

http://www.rasmussenreports.co...


[ Parent ]
I got the 68-30
from this account on TPM.  Must be job approval, and it is behind Rasmussen's paywall apparently so no way for me to verify it.

http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo...

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11


[ Parent ]
I can buy that
Favorables and approval ratings are a totally different thing. LA loves that he is fighting Obama, who, at 41%, probably has his worst approval rating in Louisiana. That gives him good approval. But a prostitution scandal will lower people's personal opinion of you, obviously.  

[ Parent ]
It just seems
incongruous with the reasonably competitive horserace numbers.

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]

Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox