Google Ads


Site Stats

OR-05: Darlene Hooley to Retire

by: Crisitunity

Thu Feb 07, 2008 at 2:34 PM EST


Uh oh; we finally have a Democratic open seat for 2008 that isn't an automatic hold. The Oregonian (via Blue Oregon) reports that Darlene Hooley is retiring in OR-05.

She says:

Hooley, 68, who spent time in the hospital in November, said health was not a reason for her decision not to seek a seventh term. "I've never felt better," she said in an interview.

Instead, she said it was the cumulative effect of arduous travel, the relentless demands of fund-raising and 32 years of public service that converged into a decision.

"At some point in everybody's life you have to decide, how much longer do I want to do this?" she said.

"It's time to move on."

OR-05 is a D+1 district. Hooley has represented it since 1996 (when she beat Jim Bunn, one of the more aberrant members of the Class of 94). She's a New Dem, and somewhat to the right of the Dem caucus's midpoint with a Progressive Punch score in the low 80s.

This district has a Democratic tradition, but it currently has a 5,000 registered voter edge for the GOP. The district is a mix of Portland burbs (the more affluent ones lean GOP, the more middle-class ones lean Dem), exurbs (very GOP), Salem (lean Dem), part of Corvallis (very Dem), and rural farm areas (very GOP). It has a rapidly growing Latino population, but they probably aren't voting much yet. (It's currently 81% white, 13% Latino. It's Oregon's 2nd most affluent district, although that's certainly skewed upwards by burbs like Lake Oswego and West Linn.)

Mike Erickson, who ran in 2006, is running again on the GOP side. He held her to about 55-45 in 2006 and can self-finance, so he has the potential to make this a very competitive race.

PolitickerOR speculates that her chief of staff, Joan Mooney Evans, will leap into the race. Another possibility they mention is new House Majority Leader Dave Hunt. A name that also occurred to me is Jim Hill, who used to represent Salem in the state senate, then was state treasurer, and most recently primaried governor Ted Kulongoski from the left in the 2006 election.

Bottom line: this will be the Dems' most difficult open seat to hold, although that's mostly by virtue of their other open seats being pretty easy. Erickson has an advantage in running a second time, but he'll be going uphill against another blue tide, and the Dems have a decent bench to pick from here.

Crisitunity :: OR-05: Darlene Hooley to Retire
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Hooley's timing is awful.
Romney dropped out today, essentially handing the GOP presidential nomination to McCain. McCain will put Oregon into play thanks to Oregonians' refusal to admit that there's no such thing as a truly moderate Republican anymore, and hasn't been since Mark Hatfield retired over a decade ago. Just like they can't bring themselves to admit that they haven't properly planned for growth, yet get offended whenever anyone brings up the issue of Portland's pathetically inadequate highway system and how no one is doing anything to manage the traffic flow to account for the metric ton of people moving there. The state Democratic party already has a major battle to fight in OR-Sen, which just got a lot harder now that McCain is the nominee and will tug on Oregonians' natural sensibilities to favor moderate Republicans, to Gordon Smith's advantage. Hooley, sitting on the biggest swing district in a not-insignificant swing state a month before the filing deadline has to pick this very moment to retire, quite possibly opening the door for a Republican to take her seat on McCain's coattails? What the hell is wrong with her?

I hope I'm wrong, but McCain is going to be competitive in Oregon and could easily win the state in November if the Democratic candidate doesn't make an effort to win back any moderate R states that have been Democratic recently but might bolt to McCain. If McCain wins Oregon, you can bet he'll take Gordo and (quite possibly) OR-05 with him. The Democrats have the fundraising and public sentiment advantage nationally, but the last thing we need right now is more competitive races in barely-blue states like Oregon.  


I don't know specifically
what the hell is wrong with her, but she's 68 and has been in and out of the hospital, so I'm assuming something is in fact wrong with her.

Oregon wasn't close in 2004, and it was close in 2000 only because of a large Nader effect. (Bush's percentage stayed the same from 2000 to 2004, while Kerry beat Gore's mark by 4%.) McCain's 'maverick' ways do play well in the Northwest, but there's a lot of anti-war sentiment in Oregon, so as long as our candidate plays up the '100 more years' remark and 'bomb bomb Iran,' he won't beat Bush's numbers by much.


[ Parent ]
Hooley ran ahead of Kerry
Bush caried the distict by 50.1% t 48.8%;  Hooley won by 30,000 votes.  Her margin was the same (although a better %) in 2006 in a Democatic year.  This one could hurt.

[ Parent ]
All right,
All right, perhaps I overstated my point, but it is still bad timing. Not that two years from now would've been better timing, but it's bad luck in any case. I wish she'd planned ahead a little more and retired in 2006, which was the best Democratic year Oregon has seen or probably will see in decades, but she probably didn't know at the time. Oh well.

As to your other points, I wouldn't call less than 2 percentage points statewide for Kerry in 2004 "wasn't close". There are 36 counties in Oregon, and Kerry only won 8 of them. Furthermore, Kerry's largest margins came from the urban parts of Multnomah, Lane, and Washington counties. OR-05 contains a piece of Washington county, but it's Lake Oswego and West Linn, two of the most affluent and Republican towns not just in the county but in the state. Clackamas county voted narrowly for Bush both times, and tends to tilt Republican. Salem is a strongly Republican town (home of many a wingnut - see troll ratings on BlueOregon), and Marion county in general voted overwhelmingly for Bush. Polk, Tillamook and Lincoln counties are all rural and pretty sparsely populated. The first two went narrowly for Bush, the third pretty substantially for Kerry. I'm not trying to sound defeatist, but it's difficult territory for any Democrat when they might be facing a bit of a McCain/Smith headwind farther up the ballot.

Also, dismissing my point by simply stating a couple of vague numbers and saying that "Oregon is anti-war" is ignoring the fact that a.) everywhere is sort of anti-war if you look at Bush disapproval stats, and b.) most of the anti-war people you mention live in Multnomah and Lane counties, neither of which is in the 5th. They can volunteer, but they can't vote. There's still a lot more support for the war in Oregon than there is in other places I've lived, and most of the pro-war dead-enders in Oregon are concentrated in places like Salem and West Linn, both of which happen to be in CD-5. Don't take any of the myths about Oregon's liberalism for granted - OR-05 is a difficult battlefield in a war that already has two other difficult battlefields (OR-Sen and OR-Pres). If HRC gets the nomination, we probably lose all three, plus most of the other Western states. Also, even if we do get Obama and he does point out how insane McCain really is, it doesn't mean that people will necessarily listen. Most Oregon voters I and my girlfriend (who's from Portland) have met are appallingly low-information and make up their minds on who to vote for based on some rumor they heard at work. This is especially true of OR-05 voters.

Basically, I wouldn't blithley and dismissively buy into any labels about non-PDX/Eugene Oregon voters' alleged liberalism if you want to actually win in November. I'm not saying it's impossible, just that it's going to take a lot of legwork to pull off, and that underestimating the difficulty of winning statewide and in OR-05 is not wise, especially if HRC gets the nomination, which she still might.  


[ Parent ]
Oops
Kerry also won Benton County in 2004, but my point still stands.  

[ Parent ]
I agree
with most of your description of the district, although it still comes across kind of defeatist... at the end of the day, this is a D+1 district, and if the shoe were on the other foot and we were facing a formerly Republican-held open seat that was D+1, given the broader trends this year, we'd probably be crowing about how it's a mortal lock, instead of doing much hand-wringing. If anything, I'd be more pessimistic about OR-Sen... we needed De Fazio or Kitzhaber to be fully competitive against Gordo.

I grew up in Corvallis, and actually canvassed all over the 5th when I was working for the Mike Kopetski campaign in 1990 (which I guess makes me officially middle-aged), so I've met many of said wingnuts. But, I also met a lot of liberals, and a whole lot of indifferent swing-voter types.

Anyway, here are a few numbers to clarify what we're talking about. In 2004, state-wide, Kerry beat Bush 51.39% to 47.19% (more than 4 pts). I guess that's still not a breathe-easy margin, but it's better than Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, or Minnesota were that year.

And Salem isn't as right-wing as you imply. Anecdotally, I found it was always a good place to canvass; it has a lot of state employees, and they tend to be Democrats. Marion County, as a whole, went for Bush 53.9% to 44.5% in 2004 (raw numbers: 57,671 to 69,903), but since a good piece of that is right-wing small logging or farming towns like Stayton, that would mean Salem itself leans Dem.

The plurality of the votes are in Clackamas County, which like you said is split almost down the middle: 48.85% for Bush, 50.1% for Kerry (95,129 to 97,691). Clackamas County does in fact include Lake Oswego and West Linn, plus Wilsonville and some unincorporated horsey-country which are also affluent, but it also includes Oregon City and Gladstone, which are more blue-collar.

Beyond that, like you said, Benton and Lincoln Counties are pretty solidly blue, and they slightly more than balance out Polk and Tillamook Counties which lean red. Overall, it's split down the middle. Not a cakewalk; it'll need money and manpower.


[ Parent ]
In case
anyone is still reading this thread, the Clackamas County numbers should be 48.8% Kerry, 50.1% Bush.

[ Parent ]
If we go off a cliff
and nominate Hillary, we will lose this seat.  This is the kind of district where we cannot afford to have higher than usual Republican turnout in and Hillary Clinton would do just that.  Nominate Hillary and lose this seat.  

Pssh
We already lost the candidate that would've netted us +20 house seats; I think we're down to the 2 where it doesn't matter whos the nominee - they'll do about as good as the other.

[ Parent ]
I Agree
We could have gone with the likeable, principled guy who could win the Republican areas.  Instead, we ended up forced to choose between a guy who's entire candidacy is "kumbayah" and a polarizing, calculated, vacillitating woman who gets a good portion of her support from ditzy people who support her because they think it would be call to have a president with a vagina.  All while the Republicans somehow ended up with arguably their most electable candidate.  

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

[ Parent ]
...but!
he had a haircut! he couldn't be president!

[ Parent ]
Which one are you talking about?
Richardson?

party: Democratic, ideology: moderate, district: CT-01

[ Parent ]
Not sure if you're being sarcastic...
... I figure you are, but I can't help but ruining it for you if that was the case by presuming you aren't, and you're just not sure.  So I'll identify him by name -- John Edwards.

[ Parent ]
Looking at past results here
This district should not be as tough as I had thought for us to hold.  While Bush carried it by an eyelash in 2000 and 2004, it went for Dukakis in 1988 by 50%-48%, 40%-35% for Clinton in 1992, and 49%-42% for Clinton in 1996.  This is not a district that is going to support a wingnut Republican in anything other than a 1994 style year.  


Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox