Google Ads


Site Stats

Washington Redistricting v.2.0

by: edward

Mon Nov 15, 2010 at 7:41 PM EST


Earlier this year I posted a diary creating a 10 district Washington State. With the update to Dave's Redistricting, I thought I would update my proposed redistricting map of Washington.

Washington has a bipartisan commission for redistricting, so at best the map is going to strive for balance or the creation of swing districts.

Photobucket

In this map, I make a return to the delegation maps of the 1960s, where the 2nd Congressional district connected Whatcom County along the Canadian border with Clallam County along the Pacific Ocean. (Actually, that district contained all or portions of Clallam, Island, Jefferson, King, San Juan, Skagit, and Snohomish Counties). Also in this map, the new 10th CD is an Tacoma (Pierce County) based district while the 3rd CD connects Bremerton with the Pacific Coast. Should this map be adopted, I would think that the delegation would be 7-3, and possibly 9-1 in a strong Democratic year if and as the cities Spokane and Yakama trend towards Democratic candidates.

Photobucket
edward :: Washington Redistricting v.2.0
CD 1 - Inslee (D - Bambridge Island) or open

White - 82%
Asian - 3%
Hispanic - 5%

Photobucket

As I wrote in the introduction, the 1st CD connects Whatcom County in the north with Jefferson County along the Olympic Peninsula. The district is connected via the Keystone to Port Townsend ferry. The district also includes the northern half of Kitsap County (Kingston and Bambridge Island), extending to the southern edge of Bremerton.

The district will be a swing (at worse) district that leans Democratic. Of the counties in the new district, Jefferson, Kitsap, and Whatcom county voted for Patty Murray, while Clallam still gave her 46%. While Rick Larsen won a squeaker in 2010, most of the Republican leaning area of his district (East Snohomish County) is now in the 2nd CD.

CD 2 - Larsen (D - Lake Stevens)

White - 83%
Asian - 6%
Hispanic - 5%

Photobucket

The 2nd is now entirely in Snohomish County. The only City not in the CD is Stanwood.

The district should be a sold Democratic district. There are 4 Democrats on the Snohomish County Council and 1 Republican. A portion of the Republican district is not in the 2nd CD, while the districts of the remaining 4 Democrats are in. Still, there is a potential for an upset in a bad year, but Patty Murray did win 51% of the vote in Snohomish County.

CD 3 - Norm Dicks (D - Bremerton)

White - 85%
Asian - 3%
Hispanic - 5%

The 3rd CD connects Bremerton in Kitsap County to Longview and Kelso in Cowlitz County. The district includes Olympia and Centralia and Chehalis in Lewis County (the district splits Lewis and Cowlitz counties [mostly down 1-5]). The district also includes Gig Harbor in Pierce County.

With Olympia and Bremerton, and as well as the Democratic lean along the Pacific Ocean (Murray won in Pacific, Gray's Harbor, and Thurston counties), the district should remain a Democratic one.

Photobucket

CD 4 - Jamie Herrara (R - Camas)

White - 79%
Hispanic - 13%

The 4th CD is a Columbia River district and extends north to the City of Yakama.

Photobucket

For the near term, this would be a Republican district. Over time, it is possible that the City of Yakama returns to its Democratic roots (the area did elect Jay Inslee in 1992) and with Vancouver, become a Democratic-performing district.

CD 5 - Cathy McMorris-Rodgers (R - Spokane)

White - 83%
Hispanic - 10%

It may not be possible to elect a Democrat east of the Cascades, but combining the Tri-Cities with Spokane may be the only way to do so. The district includes the cities of Spokane and Spokane Valley in Spokane County, but nothing to the west or north.

The district does have the advantage of placing Representative Hastings (Pasco) and McMorris-Rodgers into the same district (but I would not expect them to run against each other).

Photobucket

CD 6 - Open or Doc Hastings (R - Pasco)

White - 79%
Hispanic - 15%

This 6th CD takes in all of the rest of Eastern Washington not in the 4th or 5th and supplements that population with a small portion of Eastern Pierce County. This is a solid Republican precinct.

CD 7 - Jim McDermott (D - Seattle)

White - 68%
African American - 8%
Asian - 13%
Hispanic - 6%

This is the City of Seattle and Vashon Island. Not much to say here (except this would be one area where having city boundaries on v.2.0 would be especially nice).

CD 8 - open

White - 82%
Asian - 9%
Hispanic - 4%

This district is the district that any of the challengers to Dave Reichert would have wanted. In the north, all of the northern King County cities (and reliably Democratic) (Shoreline, Lake Forest Park, Kenmore, Kirkland, Redmond), combine with Bellevue to balance the Republican portion of east King County.

Photobucket

CD 9 - Dave Reichert (R - Auburn)

White - 71%
African American - 6%
Asian - 10%
Hispanic - 7%

Photobucket

The 9th CD retains most of its current form, extending north to Renton and east to Auburn, while it loses most of its portion of Pierce County. What remains is all (or most of the south end of King County - a distinct region in King County politics).

This swing district that never really swung, becomes a more solidly Democratic district.

CD 10 - Adam Smith (D - Tacoma)

White - 73%
African American - 8% Asian - 7%
Hispanic - 6%

The district includes Tacoma and portions of South and East Pierce County.

Pierce County is a swing County, but the Republican portions of Pierce County are not in this CD. The 6th CD has lots of east Pierce, and the 9th has a chunk of north-central Pierce County. A Democrat should retain this seat.

Photobucket

At the end of the day this map is compact, yet would probably yield a 7-3 Democratic split in the delegation most years. If there was another Republican wave, potentially 2 more Democrats could be endangered - in a Democratic wave, 2 Republicans would be endangered.
Poll
Dave's Redistricting
Love It
Like It
Love it but too distracting
Pie

Results

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

With the commission system
this is probably the best we can do. My preference would be to unpack WA-07 and spread some of the extra Democrats around, but that doesn't seem likely.

WA 7
The problem is that there is no real place for WA 7 voters to go.

Dividing Seattle North and South could work, but the districts to the North and South are already fairly Democratic. The 32nd LD (Shoreline, Edmonds, Kenmore) had an open seat for the State Senate and House, and both candidates received more than 60% of the vote. While the 9th CD is potentially competitive, the suburbs immediately South of Seattle are also good performing Democratic districts. Since these areas are already in different CDs, adding them to Seattle voters really does not accomplish much (except two super Democratic districts instead of one).

The only other way is to go East or West, neither of which make much sense geographically. There are two bridges connecting Seattle to the east side (Bellevue), but again, this area was the base for Darcy Burner and other Democratic candidates in the 8th. In my proposed map, you can shore up the 8th by adding the northern King County cities and shedding its portion of Pierce County.

If you go west, you could connect Seattle to Bremerton or Bambridge, but makes little sense geographically, and as Kitsap County is a Democratic county, so you would still have the tendency to pack Democratic voters.



[ Parent ]
3 and 6
Swap Pierce and Eastern Yakima/Klickitat. There is no viable transportation in that Yakima/Pierce corridor.

It's interesting, but I doubt the commission will put dick Hastings and Cathy Rodgers in the same district.  


Unlikely
Nice work Edward. But I agree with Gibney about the cross-mountain districts: there has to be road connection.

There was a reference on SSP's front page a few days ago and WA with 10 districts. The author was talking about the connection via the Columbia valley, like your 4th district. But it seems to me to make more sense to connect across the mountains via I-90 and/or US 2. Both of those passes are open year round and connect resonably well-populated areas on both sides. That way a district could connect parts of King and Snohomish Counties on the west side with Wenatchee, Cle Elum and possible Ellensburg to the east.

Anyway. Good work. Thanks.


Yakama/Pierce County connection
Actually, there is a state route that connects Yakama and Pierce county - through Mt. Rainier National Park. Or, if you were willing to further split Lewis County, adding Big Bottom Voting District (the NE corner of Lewis) (or the three NE most precincts), you can connect US 12 with SR 7.

Another way is to add the remainder of Lewis County to the district east of the Cascades, and add more of Yakama County to the Columbia River district.

Photobucket

This would also keep the number of county splits at a minimum.

[ Parent ]
it's closed before the election
  Ya, there's a highway through the park, but it's closed half the year. I still think your map works by spliting Klickitat County. Which is almost natural. Eastern Klickitat is associated with eastern Washington. Western Kickitat is actually almost Oregon:)

[ Parent ]

Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox