Premium Sponsor


Featured Sponsor


Our Sponsors


Ad Networks

Advertise Liberally

Buy an ad on all of the top liberal blogs with just one click.

Site Stats

Population Change by Congressional District

by: Crisitunity

Wed Sep 03, 2008 at 9:01 PM EDT


The Census Bureau recently started to release 2007 American Community Survey data for the whole country broken down by congressional district. I'm going to start with total population figures, as that may be the most important figure: while it doesn't tell us how the composition of the district has changed recently, it does give us a pretty clear picture of the trajectory different districts are on, in terms of where they'll be come redistricting time in 2010. (I'll get to income and poverty numbers in a different diary soon. Other information, such as race, education, and age, hasn't been released and won't be for a few more weeks.)

I'll start with the districts which have experienced the greatest population gain. These are the areas that will have to shed the most population (often into newly-created districts).

DistrictRep.20002007Change
AZ-06Flake (R)641,360944,706303,346
NV-03Porter (R)665,345949,685284,340
AZ-02Franks (R)641,435923,694282,259
GA-07Linder (R)630,511874,059243,548
TX-10McCaul (R)651,523889,342237,819
FL-05Brown-Waite (R)639,719870,558230,839
CA-45Bono Mack (R)638,553850,429211,876
TX-26Burgess (R)651,858843,902192,044
NC-09Myrick (R)619,705811,360191,655
TX-22Lampson (D)651,657843,070191,413
FL-14Mack (R)639,298827,747188,449
CA-44Calvert (R)639,008821,102182,094
GA-06Price (R)630,613808,518177,905
TX-03S. Johnson (R)651,782828,598176,816
AZ-07Grijalva (D)640,996797,355156,359
GA-03Westmoreland (R)630,052777,210147,158
UT-03Cannon (R)744,545891,668147,123
GA-09Deal (R)629,678774,544144,866
ID-01Sali (R)648,922791,628142,706
CO-06Tancredo (R)614,491755,315140,824
FL-08Keller (R)639,026778,960139,934
VA-10Wolf (R)643,714780,534136,820
WA-08Reichert (R)655,029790,781135,752
IL-14Foster (D)654,031787,087133,056
FL-25M. Diaz-Balart (R)638,315770,952132,637

Much more over the flip...

Crisitunity :: Population Change by Congressional District
Now here are the districts that have lost the most population between 2000 and 2007, and which will need to absorb the most surrounding territory (or be eliminated and dispersed into surrounding districts).

DistrictRep.20002007Change
LA-02Jefferson (D)639,048385,399- 253,649
PA-14Doyle (D)645,809547,019- 98,790
MI-13Kilpatrick (D)662,844568,760- 94,084
PA-02Fattah (D)647,350556,246- 91,104
OH-11vacant630,668539,938- 90,730
IL-07D. Davis (D)653,521586,439- 67,082
NY-28Slaughter (D)654,464588,681- 65,783
IL-04Gutierrez (D)653,654589,874- 63,780
MI-14Conyers (D)662,468599,005- 63,463
NY-27Higgins (D)654,200598,044- 56,156
IL-17Hare (D)653,531598,742- 54,789
CA-09Lee (D)639,426584,787- 54,639
KS-01Moran (R)672,051617,449- 54,602
AL-07A. Davis (D)635,631581,269- 54,362
MS-02B. Thompson (D)710,996656,843- 54,153
TN-09Cohen (D)631,740577,995- 53,745
PA-05Peterson (R)646,326594,617- 51,709
CA-53S. Davis (D)638,703587,042- 51,661
MN-05Ellison (D)614,874565,407- 49,467
OH-17Ryan (D)630,316581,058- 49,258
MA-08Capuano (D)635,185587,438- 47,747
OH-10Kucinich (D)631,003585,892- 45,111
MI-12Levin (D)662,559617,539- 45,020
PA-01Brady (D)645,422600,957- 44,465
MO-01Clay (D)621,497577,240- 44,257

Note the high number of Republican districts on the growth list, and the high number of Democratic districts on the shrinkage list. The first list is 25 of the districts that are some of the most archetypal exurbs, and the second list is mostly the inner cities of the Rust Belt. Now, I could go all David Brooks on you, and make the case that this spells doom for the Democrats, because Democrats are either dying out or else moving to the exurbs as complete blank slates who get turned into Republicans when they eat the magic GOP fairy dust that they sprinkle over the salad bar at Applebee's.

However, this needs to be viewed through the lens of the bluening of the people remaining in the cities, and, maybe more importantly, the bluening of the people in the inner ring suburbs. In fact, there's probably something of a ripple effect going on: people moving from the city to the inner ring suburbs, bringing their city values with them, and people already in the inner city suburbs looking around them, not liking what they see anymore, and moving further out to the exurbs. (Which isn't to say the suburbs-to-exurbs migration is consciously for racist or ideological reasons; it might be expressed purely in terms of wanting a bigger house with granite countertops, or having more elbow room separating them from neighbors. For whatever reasons, though, someone predisposed to valuing that, more so than an easier commute, a walkable neighborhood, or more interaction with neighbors, may also likelier to be predisposed to being a Republican.)

In addition, immigration plays a big factor. Traditionally, cities were the beachhead for wave after wave of immigrants in American history, but now many of them are making their first stop in the suburbs or even exurbs. As I said earlier, 2007 race data isn't available yet, but when it is, you'll see that much of the growth in the fastest growing districts (TX-10 and GA-07 especially come to mind) is non-white. (There's also another consideration: migration from other states, and people bringing their northern values with them to the Sun Belt.)

Note that this is different from a list of purely the most and least populous districts. Here are the ten most populous districts:

DistrictRep.20002007Change
NV-03Porter (R)665,345949,685284,340
AZ-06Flake (R)641,360944,706303,346
MT-ALRehberg (R)902,195933,26431,069
AZ-02Franks (R)641,435923,694282,259
UT-03Cannon (R)744,545891,668147,123
TX-10McCaul (R)651,523889,342237,819
GA-07Linder (R)630,511874,059243,548
FL-05Brown-Waite (R)639,719870,558230,839
UT-02Matheson (D)744,287857,741113,454
UT-01Bishop (R)744,377852,082107,705

And the ten least populous:

DistrictRep.20002007Change
LA-02Jefferson (D)639,048385,399- 253,649
RI-01Kennedy (D)524,189506,472- 17,717
WY-ALCubin (R)493,782508,840+ 15,058
RI-02Langevin (D)524,130512,250- 11,880
NE-03A. Smith (R)570,532537,076- 33,456
OH-11vacant630,668539,938- 90,730
PA-14Doyle (D)645,809547,019- 98,790
IA-05King (R)585,171548,055- 37,116
PA-02Fattah (D)647,350556,246- 91,104
MN-05Ellison (D)614,874565,407- 49,467

As you can see, these lists aren't quite as interesting, because of some oddball picks where states started out the decade with either very large (Montana, Utah) or very small (Rhode Island, Iowa) districts, because their populations put them on the cusp of whether or not to get an extra seat. (Or in the case of Wyoming, because there are so few people there at all.) However, I suppose it might be interesting to start a betting pool as to when Rhode Island drops to one at-large seat (2020?).

Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Matheson is not a Republican


Call no man happy until he is dead-Aeschylus

no problem


Call no man happy until he is dead-Aeschylus

[ Parent ]
This line...
Now, I could go all David Brooks on you, and make the case that this spells doom for the Democrats, because Democrats are either dying out or else moving to the exurbs as complete blank slates who get turned into Republicans when they eat the magic GOP fairy dust that they sprinkle over the salad bar at Applebee's.

...made me laugh out loud. Well done.

On another note, it seems unlikely that LA-02 will regain its population by 2010: a new study notes that New Orleans only grew 3% from 2007 to 2008, after growing 19% in the previous year.


More thoughts
You could easily see the commission drawing a creatively-drawn district that cobbles together NoLA and some of the African-American neighborhoods of Baton Rouge together in one district. That would be bad news for Don Cazayoux -- assuming he's still around in 2012.

[ Parent ]
i think that that
would fail as a racial gerrymander. What's more likely is it will take in large areas of bayou country and LA-01, while Melancon is redistricted in with Boustany, whom he shall hopefully beat.  

Call no man happy until he is dead-Aeschylus

[ Parent ]
This is the thing I don't understand about the VRA
I know the Voter's Rights Act forbids intentionally diluting a minority vote (ala TX-23 in the Delaymander), but does it require you to create ridiculously shaped districts in order to preserve one?  The most "logical" solution to the huge population loss would be to essentially merge LA-02 with parts LA-01, and create a New Orleans + suburbs district  However, this would likely dilute the already reduced Black vote of LA-02 to the point where they wouldn't be the majority any longer.  However, the Demographics of the area have changed that there isn't a coherent block of 800,000 people that has a Black majority and you'd have to go to great length to invent one.  Does the VRA mandate that this be done despite the difficulties or would the LA legislature be okay eliminating their majority minority district and blaming it on Katrina?

[ Parent ]
This doesn't
exactly answer your question, but the VRA kind of allows 'influence' or 'coalition' districts where you can meet a minority's needs by creating a district where they're 40-45% of the population, and you can fill in the blanks to get over 50% with Democratic-leaning white (or different minority) areas... like maybe some of the Cajun areas in LA-03, in this case. Since Louisiana has a Dem-controlled legislature (for now), they might be able to engineer this. (Actually, because Orleans Parish is so heavily black, it would probably still be a Dem-leaning district if it took in the Jefferson Parish portion of LA-01 instead, like you suggest. But if you're halving LA-01 then what do you do with St. Tammany Parish, above the lake? Do you join it up with LA-06, and put Cazayoux on a collision course with Scalise in a dark-red district?)

Also, the issue of 'coalition' districts is before the Supreme Court this year, so potentially the Supremes could say that only 50% or more minority population is adequate redress for a VRA claim, which facilitates 'packing' of minorities and would lead to a more Republican-favorable map. (Studies have generally shown that more 40-45% districts leads to more progressive legislators than if there's a 50%+ requirement.)


[ Parent ]
Which case is that? nt


[ Parent ]
Bartlett v. Strickland
to answer my own question.

The CBC filed an amicus brief arguing against a hard-and-fast 50% rule, as did several states (Illinois, Ohio, New Jersey, Maryland, among others), the NAACP and MALDEF.

Hopefully the 50% rule imposed by the NC Supreme Court doesn't stand. We'd be saying goodbye to plenty of seats.


[ Parent ]
Hey:
Does anybody have any numbers for the VT-AL district? I'm just asking because it is my home state, and I'd be very interested to know the change in population between 2000 and 2007, whether it increased, decreased, or stayed stagnant, just like the districts listed here.

It was
608,827 in 2000, 600,231 in 2007.

[ Parent ]
Really:
Are you serious? Wow, I had no clue my home state had lost that much population. According to The Almanac of American Politics, the 2005 population estimate was around 623,400. I guess it plunged fast.

[ Parent ]
Well, it's an estimate
rather than an actual count like in the years that end in 0, so there's room for a margin of error there. 2006 also was around 620,000, so there might have been an issue with last year's sample that caused a slightly off number. I can't think of any reason that 20,000 Vermonters might have fled last year; can you?

[ Parent ]
Canada probably invaded again
Where the Governor Douglas, being the commander in chief of the Vermont National Guard had to take to the battlefield himself, with Governors Baldacci, Patterson, and Lynch providing reinforcements while the forces from Quebec and Ontario attempted to overtake Vermont (this all happened while the Yukon invaded Alaska and Governor Palin, with two automatic rifles in hand, singlehandedly held off the invading mounties). :D

Your go-to source for great sarcasm

[ Parent ]
Maybe we need to start
Sarah Palin facts.

Bill Posey is not half-alligator...and is outclassed by Davy Crockett anyway: http://www.washingtonmonthly.c...

[ Parent ]
HAHAHAHAHA!
Thank you, they REALLY stretched to make her sound experienced in anything.  Saying Delaware can fit into Alaska 250 times, woopdy fucking doo.  He joined the Senate when she was eight, EIGHT!!!!!!

At one point, I seriously thought, who the hell are you bitch to be saying any of this mess against extremely well respected, experienced, and accomplished people.  Zero respect for her elders.  EIGHT!!!  Oh my god.

Furthermore, her belittling Obama's experience as a community organizer compared to her work for a town of 7,000.  Hell no.  Republicans dont know community organizing like we do, we actually give a shit.

I was at the speech, 100 feet away really.  I had to pull up Obama's wikipedia and go to a picture and look at it repeatedly to get me through that horrible woman's tyrade.  She said absolutely nothing productive.  Zero policy positions, just vague policy directions.

Absolute failure McCain.  Here's a link to a conversation that was picked up on a live mic between Peggy Noonan and Mike Murphy.  Sums up my sentiments exactly.  http://www.towleroad.com/2008/...

Rachel Maddow quote here also sums it up nicely. http://www.towleroad.com/2008/...


[ Parent ]
Georgia
We're going to gain a seat in 2010.  Looking at these numbers, it appears likely it'll be somewhere in the Northeast part of Metro Atlanta which is NOT good for us, at least for now.  However, if you could lop the rural counties off from GA-07 and leave it as just Gwinnett County or even parts of it, then we'd be okay as Gwinnett gets more diverse racially and more Democratic...at some point.

Follow the elections in Georgia at the 2010 Georgia Race Tracker.

The big demographic story here ...
... is that if the Democratic Party can consistently win 60% or more of the Hispanic vote, we'll be the governing party of this country for the next half century.

FL-08... say what?!?
According to the FL SoS website the 8th district had a new DECREASE of over 21,000 voters between 2006 and 2008.  Weird that the number of registered voters took a big dive yet the population is rapidly increasing...

White flight?
The number of registered Republicans in that district is dropping, but the number of registered Dems hasn't increased that dramatically in FL-08. We all know that this Orlando-based district is seeing an influx of Puerto Rican newcomers. Might some whites be fleeing and the new residents not registering to vote in great numbers?

[ Parent ]
Certainly by 2030
My back of the envelope calculations have Montana becoming larger than Rhode Ireland in population terms by around 2018 and global warming is likely to benefit Montana's population growth but not Rhode Island's.

I wouldn't absolutely bet on it happening by 2020, but Rhode Island's best case scenario is that it's Utah-North Carolina close then and none of the larger states can claim priority on its second seat. And that seems unlikely.



Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

Talk to your supporters, not tech support. Campaign Engine is the powerful, affordable Progressive Campaign Software.

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

SSP Race Ratings

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox