Google Ads


Site Stats

CA-20: Costa in a Dogfight?

by: James L.

Wed Sep 15, 2010 at 2:36 PM EDT


SurveyUSA for KFSN-TV (9/10-12, likely voters, no trend lines):

Jim Costa (D-inc): 48
Andy Vidak (R): 46
Undecided: 6
(MoE: ±4.2%)

Jim Costa's coming off a whopping 74-26 win over unheralded GOP challenger Jim Lopez in 2008, but SurveyUSA thinks that cherry farmer Andy Vidak is within striking distance of an upset here this fall. The 20th District is at least somewhat competitive, having gone for John Kerry by only three points over Bush in 2004 (but also supporting Obama by 60-39 in '08 and Al Gore by 55-44 a decade ago). One big red flag is SUSA's estimation of the Hispanic turnout: they're pegging it at just 30%. (Note that this CD was 63% Hispanic as of 2000.) In what appears to be an effort to preemptively address criticism with their sample's demographics, SUSA broke with their normal practice and banged out the following:

* If Hispanics make up 30% of voters on Election Day, Costa and Vidak finish effectively even, Costa 48%, Vidak 46%, within the survey's theoretical margin of sampling error. At this hour, Republicans are, subject to change as the campaign unfolds, within reach of a take-way. If Hispanic turnout is 30% or less on election day, other turnout issues, such as the number of males vs females, could potentially come into play and help decide the contest.
* If Hispanics make up 35% of voters on Election Day, Costa is better positioned to hold the seat for the Democrats: he would lead today by approximately 7 points, 50% to 43% in a hypothetical analysis conducted by SurveyUSA.
* If Hispanics make up 40% of voters on Election Day, Costa today would lead by approximately 11 points, 52% to 41%, according to a hypothetical analysis conducted by SurveyUSA.

Meanwhile, in the open seat race to replace George "Who?" Radanovich, GOP state Sen. Jeff Denham leads physician/attorney Loraine Goodwin by 63-30.

James L. :: CA-20: Costa in a Dogfight?
Tags: , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

I wonder
if all those Vidak signs I saw lined up by the side of I-5 are really having a an effect?

These are the same signs that say "Stop Pelosi, Boxer, and Costa"
"Congress created the Dustbowl"

Male 21 Dem Ca's 1st  


I saw those signs too on vacation this year.
But apparently, there's nothing new about them.  Back in the day, they had signs that said stuff like "Impeach Earl Warren."

Ad hoc, ad loc and quid pro quo!
So little time, so much to know!


[ Parent ]
When I came back to socal from SF I saw all those signs
And I was wondering, how is this a democratic district?!  Seems like the rural crappyness and it's seemingly baseless blame on congress for a "Dustbowl" I have never heard of would make this a quite conservative district.

I'm no fan of Costa, but everyone is saying Costa holds this seat, even Nate silver says he holds it.

I have no faith in SUSA anymore.

20, Male, Democrat, CA-44 (home) CA-12 (college)


[ Parent ]
I was looking at this district
and saw that both Kings and Kern County do cut through Costa's district (which probably explains the conservative tinge I felt while driving though).

Male 21 Dem Ca's 1st  

[ Parent ]
While Kings is completely in Costa's district
only part of Kern is, and then the CA-20 part of Kern went for Obama 2:1. My guess is most of those "congress created the dust bowl" signs are probably in McCarthy's share of Kern County, which went McCain also by 2:1.

My blog
Twitter
Scribd
28, New Democrat, Female, TX-03 (hometown CA-26)


[ Parent ]
Those Central Valley signs are pretty silly...
but the most disturbing one is a full-size billboard that reads "Produce the Birth Certificate."  It's on I-5 in Willows, Glenn County (CA-02).

[ Parent ]
I don't know what's in the water
at SUSA, but they've released some rather apocalyptic numbers for the democrats in many races over the past month.  This one seems somewhat more believable, but their numbers are always the worst for our side of any pollster it seems, including Rassmussen.  

That and their results have been rather poor ever since the 2008 election cycle.  

23, Male, Democrat, OH-13


I Wonder Too
There must be something wrong with the "secret sauce." I think it's a lack of proper weighting.

[ Parent ]
If they're numbers are right
we would be looking at 75-100 seat loss. I'm a pessimist but  I don't buy that. Maybe Tekzilla does.

[ Parent ]
SUSA
I don't buy a 75-100 Seat loss.  I think the most likely range is 25-50.

29/D/Male/NY-01

[ Parent ]
He lives!
I miss you man!  Congratulations on being right abou everything all cycle.

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]
Yup, we are all Tekzilla now, n/t


[ Parent ]
Who had Burns beating Critz the day before the PA-12 election?
Was that SUSA?

23, Male, PA-05 (summer) PA-12 (winter)

PPP by 1 point
I don't remember if SUSA polled it at all.

[ Parent ]
Pretty much everyone did
Most polls has Burns beating Critz.  Again that district is extremely hard to poll.  When its a rural district, automatically distrust the polling.  

While this district is mainly centered around Fresno, the rural areas probably make it harder to poll.  Either those areas are oversampled or undersampled.  Considering the population centers in that region tend to be Republican and the smaller areas far more Democratic, the sample size could be distorted that way.  I-5 goes through some really Republican territory in CA-20 too so any observation based on it can be potentially distorted.

It is a D+5 district so it could potentially fall in a bad environment for the Democrats, but for the Hispanic vote not to show up in this district or lean more Republican would mean doom elsewhere too.

23, male, center-right cynical Republican, PA-7


[ Parent ]
I'm pretty sure the I-5 signs are intentionally inflammatory
That corridor is indeed strongly Republican, and they want to scare the city slickers into voting Republican by invoking Grapes of Wrath imagery (which, I believe, is mandatory CA high school reading).  And I do think they're scaring people to some extent, but probably not in the way they intend to - I, for one, have become afraid of the types of people I might meet at the fruit stands, and now just drive straight through to Pea Soup Andersen's.

[ Parent ]
it's not


18, Dem, CA-14 (home) CA-09 (college, next year). social libertarian, economic liberal, fiscal conservative.   Everybody should put age and CD here. :)

[ Parent ]
Costa will win
He might have a reduced majority, but he will still win, as he's a good fit for the district. The district is very rural on paper, but what keeps it remotely Democratic are the Dem precincts in Fresno and Bakersfield. The Republican margin is in Kings County.  

24, male, African-American, CA-24, Democrat. Chair of the SSP Black Caucus.

I don't trust SUSA at all anymore, after Stu Rothenberg's takedown of their VA-05 polling......
Rothenberg wrote earlier this week that the SUSA VA-05 polls are a joke because, as Rothenberg is privy to knowing, private polling in both the Hurt and Perriello camps show Hurt leading only narrowly, not by a monstrous margin like SUSA says.

Between that definitive smackdown, and the fact so many of SUSA's polls are suspicious on their face, I don't trust SUSA anymore.

I think this just shows the limits of robopolling.  PPP has been much better so far this year, but every robopollster seems to go off the deep end at times even after initially building a good reputation.

43, male, Indian-American, Democrat, VA-10


i suspect
SUSA would show Republicans close or winning in almost every district in which a Republican challenger has raised six figures.  If SUSA polled every district, I bet they would show well over 100 Dem seats in serious danger.

34, WM, Democrat, FL-11

[ Parent ]
1 in 3 AA's voting Republican?
SUSA SUCKSA.

Agriculture and CA-20
I seem to remember a reference to farmers in California showing more discontent than usual with the federal government, which might be why we're seeing unexpected Republican strength in CA-20 (and CA-18 if there's any there.) I know there's been a drought there and they're not happy about the water situation. But of course it's hard to blame the lack of rain on Democrats, not that that necessarily deters people...    

36, M, Democrat, MD-03

AA sample size small
This district is 7% African American.  The sample size for them probably has a margin of error of 15%.

23, male, center-right cynical Republican, PA-7

[ Parent ]
Unemployment in Fresno
While it seems unlikely that Costa will lose, unemployment rate in Fresno was at 16.2% in July 2010 vs. 11.9% back when he was reelected in November 2008.  It was as high as 18.6% earlier this year, so people are really hurting there, whether Hispanic, white, or black.  I wonder if recent excessively high unemployment will have any correlation with seat losses for Dems in November for typically safe Dem seats?  

30% Hispanic turn-out in a 63% Hispanic district...
That's just sad.

If this were 63% black, Costa would automatically get 63% of the vote.

On the other hand, if this district were 63% Asian, a 30% Asian electorate might not be ridiculous. That's also pretty sad.

http://mypolitikal.com/


That 63% is artificially high
From what I know (and feel from to correct me if you're from CA) a large segment of Central Valley Hispanics do not vote because they are either unregistered or ineligible (as either documented or undocumented aliens.) Non-citizens count toward the Hispanic percentage when the Census is taken, but my guess is that the electorate in this district is only about 45% Hispanic--and that's before you apply any likely voter screens.

20, CD MA-03/NH-01/MA-08

[ Parent ]
In addition, Hispanics are younger than average as well
a.k.a. more "potential" voters still under 18.

FWIW, the CNN exit poll from '08 had 18% Hispanic voters in CA, even though they make up 2x that proportion of the CA population.


[ Parent ]
Costa
and other Central Valley Democrats better hold on tight. Expect Whitman and Fiorina to sweep the Central Valley in November, especially since they have been beating the water issue to death. Plus unemployment is especially high in this region and the Central Valley has always been one of the more GOP leaning areas of the state.

Also Costa did barely win this seat in 2004 against State Senate Roy Asburn (who recently was forced to come out of the closet).

19, Male, Independent, CA-12


This is even less substantive than most of my posts
But when I was glancing at this I misread the title as "Coats in a Dogfight?" and nearly had a heart attack.

Also, this seat isn't one I'm feeling too good about. Regardless of how much SUSA's House polling sucks, this race has rapidly moved onto the radar for me, and numbers like these don't help.  

Independent Socialist & Chair of SSP Cranky Indianian Hoosier Caucus, IN-09


CA-20
I have been suspecting that this would be a darkhorse race for awhile. Added to the anger that is typical in most districts, voters here are very upset about the water situation. This poll confirms that.

I don't buy these results
I don't think Costa will win in a blowout, but a 2 point margin doesn't add up.  I'd think Costa will win by around 10 points.

40, male, Democrat, NC-04

Since he is still winning
I'll take that as a good sign. Especially considering the source and the problems they seem to be having with House polls, as they did in 2008.

This is a very good poll by SurveyUSA....
63% of the population is Hispanic, 40% can vote, 30% will vote in a year like 2010.

The anti-Costa, anti-Cardoza, Dust Bowl signs are particularly everywhere. This maybe one of the seats that wasn't suspected to fall, but is close.

All I can say is the Hispanic weighting of 40% makes no sense at all.  It's less.

28, Liberal Democrat, CA-26


I would test the waters here if I were NRCC...
but not overcommit, knowing that Vidak will be gerried out if Jerry wins.  The only way I see the GOP holding on to the seat under a Dem map is if both Cardoza and Costa lose.


Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

You're not running for second place. Is your website? See why Campaign Engine is ranked #1 in software and support among Progressive-only Internet firms. http://www.mediamezcla.com/

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox