Premium Sponsor


Featured Sponsor


Our Sponsors


Ad Networks

Advertise Liberally

Buy an ad on all of the top liberal blogs with just one click.

Site Stats

Minnesota Redistricting Maps

by: Alibguy

Tue Jul 07, 2009 at 11:25 AM EDT


Here is another Democratic gerrymander. I chose Minnesota because the majority of the poll voters picked it. For those of you who voted for Georgia, that is my next state.  For Minnesota, a gerrymander like this is possible but it could be a long shot. This would only happen if the Democrats retain the State Legislature and capture the Governorship. I drew this map assuming that Minnesota would lose one electoral vote. I probably was able to create a 6-1 Democratic map even though there is a chance it might be a 5-2 Democratic map. My main objectives were to keep all Democrats safe while weakening Republican Erik Paulsen of the 3rd district and combining Republicans John Kline and Michelle Bachman. They are both so Conservative so at least we can knock away one of them. The pink lines are the boundaries of the old districts.  Here is the link to my maps http://frogandturtle.blogspot.com

District 1 Tim Walz (D) Blue
Even though I would have loved to strengthen Walz but I could do that because I needed enough Democratic counties to protect Collin Peterson (D) in the 6th district. Anyway, this district is pretty much the same as it is except I took in Democratic leaning Rice and Lincoln Counties as well Le Suer and part of Goodhue County. Le Suer and Goodhue are both marginal. I probably raised the Obama performance in the district by just a bit. I estimate that Obama won 52% to 53% of the vote here. The racial stats are 91% White. Status is Likely Democrat.

District 2 John Kline (R) vs. Michelle Bachman (R) Green
I have heard some talk from Republicans about combining Minneapolis and St. Paul into one district. I bet they did not consider that the Democrats could combine most of the Republican suburban areas into one district. I strengthened the 2nd district's Republican performance by adding more Republican territory near St. Cloud and removing Rice County. McCain probably won only 55% of the vote here so a strong Democrat could possibly make it competitive. Michelle Bachman's home Stillwater is in the district. The 2nd district contains part of her old 6th so she will probably choose to run here. John Kline is more entrenched so he will probably win, forcing Michelle Bachman to finally get out of Congress. Racial stats are 90% White. Status is Safe Republican if Kline wins, Likely Republican if Bachman wins.

District 3 Erik Paulsen (R) Purple
I know one thing about this district; Paulsen is in for a tough race with this district. He was elected in 2008 so he had almost no time to become entrenched into his district. To weaken him, I removed part of western Hennepin County, put in the most urban parts of Washington County and added some heavily Democratic areas in Minneapolis. Paulsen won by eight points in 2008 against Ashwin Maida, an impressive candidate. This definitely drops the chances of clearly knocking off Paulsen but with some new territory, it should be much easier. Obama won 56%-57% of the vote here. Racial stats are 8% African American, 6% Asian and 81% White. Status is Toss Up/Tilt Democratic.

District 4 Betty McCollum (D) Red
Her district looks very different from the one she has now. I had to unfortunately extend it out into the Republican suburbs because of population loss and the elimination of Michelle Bachman's district. Her district extends all the way out to St. Cloud now. Ramsey County gave Obama a margin of 96,000 votes and the part McCollum has Obama probably pulled out a 75,000 vote margin there. The suburban part of the district probably gave McCain a 15,000 vote margin. A 60,000 Obama margin should be enough to protect McCollum. If Bachman decided to run here, she would probably not win. Obama probably won 59% of the vote here. The racial stats are 6% African American, 6% Asian, 6% Hispanic and 79% White. Status is Safe Democrat.

District 5 Keith Ellison (D) Yellow
Even though I slipped in part of the old 3rd district, Keith Ellison should have no worries. Minneapolis will keep him safe and sound. Obama probably won here with 68%-72% of the vote. Racial stats are 10% African American, 8% Hispanic, 5% Asian and 73% White. Status is Safe Democrat.

District 6 Collin Peterson (D) Teal
Even though I have tried to strengthen every Democrat here, I had to weaken Peterson a bit. I took away a few northern Counties that lean Democratic and added some of Stearns and Sherburne Counties which lean Republican. I may have compensated for those counties by adding a touch of Minneapolis. Weakening Peterson should not hurt him much. He is a moderate Democrat who is the chairman of the Agriculture Committee and has been representing the 7th district since 1991. He should be safe even though McCain probably won 51% of the vote here. Racial stats are 90% White. Status is Safe Democrat.

District 7 James Oberstar (D) Gray
This district has slow population growth so I had to extend it to the North Dakota border. The counties there lean Democratic so the new additions do not alter the 7th district's political leanings much. It would not matter how many Republicans are here because Oberstar has represented this district since the 1970's. He creamed former Senator Rod Grams when he ran for House in 2006. No question about it, Oberstar is safe. Obama probably received 56% of the vote here. Racial stats are 93% White. Status is Safe Democrat.

Alibguy :: Minnesota Redistricting Maps
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Congratulations on your Rorschach splotches
That's pretty much the only way to describe this map.

There's a key on your keyboard that says "print screen"
or some abbreviation that means print screen.
It copies a picture of your entire screen that you can later paste into paint and save as a picture file. It's much better than taking a photo of your monitor with a camera. I don't mean any offense. I'm just saying, doing this will really improve the quality of your diaries.

Been through this with him
he refuses.

[ Parent ]
I had a silimar idea
To spread the Oberstar district across the entire northern part of the state.

The yellow district is a Republican district, but if it's Peterson vs Bachman then I think Peterson would win it.

Nope
Peterson would not hold that district.  He doesn't live in it first off, and then secondly you put pretty much put the most Republican counties into his district excluding carver and Scott which now makes Paulsen 100percent safe.  There is no way Kline can hold his district now though but Bachmann I think would have a better than 50/50 shot at winning against Peterson.

The Oberstar/Iron Range district doesn't need any shoring up and still dominates at the local level when expanded south into the exurbs.  Peterson's district actually has DFL majorities in the state house and senate and so I never get why everyone wants to screw over and dissasemble either one of these districts to help the other.  The current CD8 is actually an easy hold (think open OH6 in 2006) and it's probably 50/50 for the old CD7 and that's as good as it will get.


[ Parent ]
On the other hand
Bachmann doesn't live in that district or anywhere near it, and Peterson represented many of those Republican counties prior to 2002.  

[ Parent ]
Bachmann would certainly move
And his old district didn't include nearly as much exurbs and that district voted roughly 44/54 McCain and I'm too lazy to do the Bush numbers but I'm sure he got over 60percent.  If Peterson were to hold on, it'd be certain defeat when he retired and that's dumb when we'd stand a fighting chance by just expanding his district south instead of radically changing it

[ Parent ]
Bachman just moved this past year
Not saying she wouldn't move again but I have my doubts. I will stick to my prediction that Bachmann runs for Senate in 2012, gets crushed, and then lands a gig on FOX.

[ Parent ]
Bachmann, I'm assuming
she'll be Palin's running mate ;-)

[ Parent ]
I think that all sounds really likely
She knows her days are numbered and when I heard she was moving to Woodbury from Stillwater, my immediate reaction was, wtf?  She made it insanely easy just to throw her house in with McCollum and call her a done deal.  She must not be planning to stick around.

[ Parent ]
That looks like a GOP Gerrymander of the state
Pack Urban Blue voters, check. Pack Rural Blue voters, check. Maximizes districts for suburban / exurban Red voters, check.

[ Parent ]
really
It was supposed to be 4 safe D, 1 safe R, 2 toss up. Although I am aware those 2 tossup districts already have R incumbents.
I remember a few weeks ago someone posted a Minnesota map that had 3 safe D districts around the twin cities area, but I can't find it.
If we keep all 3 rural districts then they will have to get bigger and encroach on the Republican outer suburbs of the twin cities area. There is a danger they could go Republican when their incumbents retire. That's why it might be smarter to sacrifice one of them to keep the other 2 safe D. Collin Peterson should be free to represent his district in its current form for as long as he wants. But if he does decide to retire in time for redistricting then I would advocate cutting it up as shown. Besides, the diarist's Peterson district with a finger into Minneapolis will never happen.

[ Parent ]
oh that was mine
http://www.swingstateproject.c...

I definitely think once Peterson retires and if it is an R incumbent or we get to redistrict an open seat, your map is something we should do with the one thing to change is put Kline in the new hardcore GOP seat and leave that suburban seat open as it'd be a total swing district.

But definitely, without Peterson (or another DFLer) holding his seat, we can radically change it up as you've pointed out, these seats will just have to get closer and closer into the cities and included exurbia.  While I think we are fine for now with our solid incumbents, if these areas continue to grow as rapidly as they have been (exurbia MN is a hard hit area for the housing market which is quite indicative), then your map would be a really great one.  In fact, if you traded suburban and exurban parts with the Paulsen and Kline districts you made, you could probably make a really coherent 5/2 map, 2 safe DFL city seats, 1 safe Iron Range/Northern MN seat, 1 seat Walz keeps safe, 1 lean Dem suburban, and then 1 safe GOP exurban and 1 safe GOP exurban/suburban.


[ Parent ]
yeah, definitely
the more I look at your map, the more I like it if we no longer have to protect Peterson.

[ Parent ]
That's the best Minnesota map I've seen so far
Do you live in MN? You clearly know it pretty well. I hope you don't mind that I added tags to your diary.
I would gladly shift the suburban districts into something that works better.

[ Parent ]
yup
Live in St Paul, vote back at my permanent address as I've got Bachmann.  I spent a good couple of months on that (still need to finish my 8 seater) so I've really gotten to know MN and it's voting patterns in every area of the state.  There are a lot of different ways to redistrict MN with varying rural vs metro, exurban vs suburban vs urban seats, fun state to chat about as it's so diverse politically.

[ Parent ]
bad map mainly becuase the
state isn't losing a congressional district soo...back to the drawing board.

You really did pack the Democrats into two districts, while making Kline's district slight more Democratic but not unfeasible.

You really hurt Walz as well.

Call no man happy until he is dead-Aeschylus


[ Parent ]
I really like what you did with CD3
Although a few tweaks, lose Lake Elmo and parts of Woodbury in Washington County to take in Cottage Grove in Washington County and you could touch point to add in Hastings from Dakota County, so you CD2 can still snake around to take in some Washington County townships.  Both Hastings and Cottage Grove are bluer than Lake Elmo and Woodbury.   Although, you have CD2 snake all the way up to Stillwater in Washington County, which is also bluer than Woodbury and Lake Elmo so I'd definitely put Stillwater somewhere else as well.  Same with Red Wing down in Goodhue County, that city is BLUE BLUE BLUE  and should be in Walz's district to shore him up so I'd trade that with some townships from CD1.  But great basis for keeping CD3 all suburban but still making it bluer, there is just a little more tweaking that could occur to make it perfect and the most blue possible.  This is something Id love to try and redo for my own 7 seat map.  I made CD3 half Minneapolis but keeping it all suburban and just shifting which ones it takes in could be very similar to a Philly suburban district.

I wont start on CD6 as I heavily criticize everyone who tries to fuck with the two northern Greater Minnesota districts.  Just leave them alone and expand them south, one will stay safe Dem and one will stay a swing district.  Everyone seems to shore one up at the expense of the other and it's all so needless, that Iron Range district is 100% safe but could become swing if you lessen its Dem margin by even like 5% as the exurbs will get more of a deciding factor.  There is no need to shore it up, just a need to make sure it's still dominated by the Iron Range/Duluth as then the DFL can nominate an Iron Ranger and pretty much dominate in this district.  And we cant ask for much else with Peterson's district, I still think we have an excellent shot at keeping it if he retires, the rural counties of MN are where Obama KILLED percentage wise compared to Kerry so who knows.  I should also look up how many state house and senate seats we've gained here since 2004 as the DFL has gained like 40 house seats since then.

Although Id love to see how your CD6 voted, it does a lot of weird snaking into the cities and exurbs and I wonder how everything cancels each other out.  You put St. Cloud in CD6 right?  That's a 2000 vote margin for Obama, the exurbs certainly cancel that out and then add in some GOP margin, but then you include the immediate north burbs of Minneapolis which are easily 2-to-1 for Obama, if not more.  Peterson's district currently includes some HEAVILY GOP areas of Stearns county so you probably did better than you think if it were all totaled up.  Or you are exactly right, heh.


No, I am not ignoring you
Alot of you (you know who you are) suggested I use different methods to post the maps and said I will not listen. After hearing you, I will finally take some of your suggestions.

For more election analysis, visit frogandturtle.blogspot.com


Copyright 2003-2010 Swing State Project LLC

Primary Sponsor

Talk to your supporters, not tech support. Campaign Engine is the powerful, affordable Progressive Campaign Software.

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About the Site

SSP Resources

SSP Race Ratings

Blogroll

Powered by: SoapBlox