AK-Sen, MN-Sen: SSP Moves Both Races to "Tossup"

by: James L.

Mon Oct 13, 2008 at 4:56 AM EDT

After enjoying a brief bounce in the polls with the news of Stevens' indictment, Begich's numbers have come back down to earth, with one Rasmussen poll even showing Stevens taking a marginal lead. There's no denying that Stevens is an institution within Alaska, and it's not surprising that many voters feel reluctant to dump a man who has been representing the state in Washington for 40 years.

But most unsettling to us is what appears to be a very bungled prosecution of Stevens by the Feds. Due to sheer (willful?) mismanagement, Stevens' federal prosecutors have seen key evidence been thrown out by Judge Emmet Sullivan, and stomach-turning fuck-ups like this one:

"Jurors will be instructed that the government presented evidence to those jurors that the government knew was not true," Judge Sullivan told both sides this afternoon.

It would be no shock if Stevens received a full acquittal, which would be a huge boost to his re-election chances. That turn of events might not be fatal for Begich, but it would make this race significantly harder. With the trial's outcome so uncertain, we no longer see a clear edge for Begich in this race.

Some recent polls have shown a lot of volatility, and the three most recent surveys all give leads of varying sizes to Franken. But one thing is also clear: Dean Barkley has emerged as a real spoiler in this race, consistently gobbling up a share of the vote in the mid-to-high teens in the polls -- and at least some polling suggests that Barkley is cutting deeper into Coleman's share of the pie than he is against Franken's.

Perhaps sensing real danger, Coleman has made the move of pulling all of his negative ads from the airwaves. It remains to be seen whether this turns out to be too little, too late, but it is an indication that Coleman feels the need for a major strategic reorientation.